e-ISSN: Pending

Browse the failure-mode index

35 real negative results, null findings, and replication failures in Earth and Planetary Sciences. Search the index →

WASTE indexes published research — it does not host or republish full papers. Each entry is a metadata record compiled from open scholarly databases; the abstract is shown in full only where the paper is openly licensed, otherwise a short excerpt under fair use. Classifications are automated and approximate.

Negative / Null Result ReportEarth and Planetary Sciences

Long‐term ozone trends at rural ozone monitoring sites across the United States, 1990–2010

Owen R. Cooper, R. S. Gao, D. W. Tarasick et al. · 2012 · Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres

This analysis provides an up‐to‐date assessment of long‐term (1990–2010) rural ozone trends using all available data in the western (12 sites) and eastern (41 sites) USA. Rather than focus solely on average ozone values or air quality…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Comparative performance of the BGISEQ-500 vs Illumina HiSeq2500 sequencing platforms for palaeogenomic sequencing

Sarah S. T. Mak, Shyam Gopalakrishnan, Christian Carøe et al. · 2017 · GigaScience

Ancient DNA research has been revolutionized following development of next-generation sequencing platforms. Although a number of such platforms have been applied to ancient DNA samples, the Illumina series are the dominant choice today, mainly because of high production capacities and short read production. Recently a potentially attractive alternative platform for palaeogenomic data generation has been developed, the BGISEQ-500, whose sequence output are comparable with the Illumina series. In this study, we modified the standard BGISEQ-500 library preparation specifically for use on degraded

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportEarth and Planetary Sciences

Meteorological Causes of the Secular Variations in Observed Extreme Precipitation Events for the Conterminous United States

Kenneth E. Kunkel, David R. Easterling, David A. R. Kristovich et al. · 2012 · Journal of Hydrometeorology

Abstract Daily extreme precipitation events, exceeding a threshold for a 1-in-5-yr occurrence, were identified from a network of 935 Cooperative Observer stations for the period of 1908–2009. Each event was assigned a meteorological cause,…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

BAYSPLINE: A New Calibration for the Alkenone Paleothermometer

Jessica E. Tierney, Martin P. Tingley · 2018 · Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology

Abstract The alkenone‐based U proxy is a cornerstone of paleoclimatology, providing insight into the temperature history of the Earth's surface ocean. Although the relationship between U and sea surface temperatures (SSTs) is robust and…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Quantifying Environmental Control on Tropical Cyclone Intensity Change

Eric A. Hendricks, Melinda S. Peng, Bing Fu et al. · 2010 · Monthly Weather Review

Abstract Composite analysis is used to examine environmental and climatology and persistence characteristics of tropical cyclones (TCs) undergoing different intensity changes in the western North Pacific (WPAC) and North Atlantic (ATL)…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Evaluation of dust and trace metal estimates from the Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) model version 5.0

K. Wyat Appel, George Pouliot, Heather Simon et al. · 2013 · Geoscientific model development

Abstract. The Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) model is a state-of-the-science air quality model that simulates the emission, transformation, transport, and fate of the many different air pollutant species that comprise particulate matter (PM), including dust (or soil). The CMAQ model version 5.0 (CMAQv5.0) has several enhancements over the previous version of the model for estimating the emission and transport of dust, including the ability to track the specific elemental constituents of dust and have the model-derived concentrations of those elements participate in chemistry. The late

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Observed suppression of ozone formation at extremely high temperatures due to chemical and biophysical feedbacks

Allison L. Steiner, Adam J. Davis, Sanford Sillman et al. · 2010 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Ground level ozone concentrations ([O(3)]) typically show a direct linear relationship with surface air temperature. Three decades of California measurements provide evidence of a statistically significant change in the ozone-temperature…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Evaluation of 23 gridded precipitation datasets across West Africa

Frédéric Satgé, Dimitri Defrance, Benjamin Sultan et al. · 2019 · Journal of Hydrology

This study aims reporting on 23 gridded precipitation datasets (P-datasets) reliability across West Africa through direct comparisons with rain gauges measurement at the daily and monthly time scales over a 4 years period (2000–2003). All…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Multi-species collapses at the warm edge of a warming sea

Gil Rilov · 2016 · Scientific Reports

Even during the current biodiversity crisis, reports on population collapses of highly abundant, non-harvested marine species were rare until very recently. This is starting to change, especially at the warm edge of species' distributions where populations are more vulnerable to stress. The Levant basin is the southeastern edge of distribution of most Mediterranean species. Coastal water conditions are naturally extreme, and are fast warming, making it a potential hotspot for species collapses. Using multiple data sources, I found strong evidence for major, sustained, population collapses of t

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

A palaeo Tibet–Myanmar connection? Reconstructing the Late Eocene drainage system of central Myanmar using a multi-proxy approach

Alexis Licht, Christian France‐Lanord, Laurie Reisberg et al. · 2013 · Journal of the Geological Society

Strain resulting from the collision of India with Asia has caused fundamental changes to Asian drainage patterns, but the timing and nature of these changes are poorly understood. One frequently proposed hypothesis involves the connection of the palaeo Tsangpo drainage to a precursor to the Irrawaddy River of central Myanmar in the Palaeogene. To test this hypothesis, we studied the provenance of Palaeogene fluvio-clastic sedimentary rocks that crop out in central Myanmar, namely the Late Middle Eocene–Early Oligocene Pondaung and Yaw Formations. Isotopic analysis on bulk-rock and petrographic

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

The floatingSargassum(Phaeophyceae) of the South Atlantic Ocean – likely scenarios

Marina Nasri Sissini, Maria Beatriz Barbosa de Barros Barreto, Maria Teresa Menezes de Széchy et al. · 2017 · Phycologia

:This study represents the efforts of a network of researchers to characterise the large, floating Sargassum (Fucales, Phaeophyceae) biomass that had reached the Brazilian coast in 2014 and 2015. Material collected during these events was…

View details →
Replication FailureEarth and Planetary Sciences

Tree‐ring analysis and modeling approaches yield contrary response of circumboreal forest productivity to climate change

Shunsuke Tei, Atsuko Sugimoto, Hitoshi Yonenobu et al. · 2017 · Global Change Biology

Circumboreal forest ecosystems are exposed to a larger magnitude of warming in comparison with the global average, as a result of warming-induced environmental changes. However, it is not clear how tree growth in these ecosystems responds…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Recent Sea Ice Decline Did Not Significantly Increase the Total Liquid Freshwater Content of the Arctic Ocean

Qiang Wang, Claudia Wekerle, Sergey Danilov et al. · 2018 · Journal of Climate

Abstract The freshwater stored in the Arctic Ocean is an important component of the global climate system. Currently the Arctic liquid freshwater content (FWC) has reached a record high since the beginning of the last century. In this…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Geospatial Distributions of Groundwater Quality in Gedaref State Using Geographic Information System (GIS) and Drinking Water Quality Index (DWQI)

Basheer A. Elubid, Tao Huang, Ekhlas H. Ahmed et al. · 2019 · International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health

The observation of groundwater quality elements is essential for understanding the classification and distribution of drinking water. Geographic Information System (GIS) and remote sensing (RS), are intensive tools for the performance and analysis of spatial datum associated with groundwater sources control. In this study, groundwater quality parameters were observed in three different aquifers including: sandstone, alluvium and basalt. These aquifers are the primary source of national drinking water and partly for agricultural activity in El Faw, El Raha (Fw-Rh), El Qalabat and El Quresha (Qa

View details →
Failed Experiment ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Crystal Size Distribution (CSD) Analysis of Volcanic Samples: Advances and Challenges

K. V. Cashman · 2020 · Frontiers in Earth Science

Studies of magmatic systems have long used the textures of erupted samples to infer processes that control the location and duration of magma storage and drive volcanic eruptions from these storage regions. Models of volcanic processes and magmatic systems have evolved substantially over the past decades, in large part because of advances in analytical and experimental techniques. Cooling- and decompression-experiments have greatly enhanced our understanding of crystal textures produced by crystallization associated with volcanic eruptions, while advances in compositional mapping, isotopic ana

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Globigerinoides ruber morphotypes in the Gulf of Mexico: A test of null hypothesis

Kaustubh Thirumalai, Julie N. Richey, Terrence M. Quinn et al. · 2014 · Scientific Reports

Planktic foraminifer Globigerinoides ruber (G. ruber), due to its abundance and ubiquity in the tropical/subtropical mixed layer, has been the workhorse of paleoceanographic studies investigating past sea-surface conditions on a range of…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Chloroplast symbiosis in a marine ciliate: ecophysiology and the risks and rewards of hosting foreign organelles

George B. McManus, Donald M. Schoener, Katharine Haberlandt · 2012 · Frontiers in Microbiology

Simultaneous use of both heterotrophic and autotrophic metabolism ("mixotrophy") is common among protists. Strombidium rassoulzadegani is a planktonic mixotrophic marine ciliate that saves chloroplasts from its algal food and obtains a nutritional subsidy via photosynthesis. Cultures from the northeast, northwest, and southwest Atlantic Ocean show similar numerical response parameters (maximum growth rate, food concentration at which growth is half its maximum, and threshold food concentration for growth), and some isolates have been maintained in vitro for over 3 years. This ciliate grows equ

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportEarth and Planetary Sciences

Amundsen and Bellingshausen Seas simulation with optimized ocean, sea ice, and thermodynamic ice shelf model parameters

Yoshihiro Nakayama, Dimitris Menemenlis, Michael Schodlok et al. · 2017 · Journal of Geophysical Research Oceans

Abstract Recent studies suggest that the thickness of Winter Water (WW), that is, water with potential temperature below ∼−1°C located below Antarctic Surface Water and above Circumpolar Deep Water (CDW) is critical in determining the ice…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Global biogeography of Albian ammonoids: A network-based approach

Alexis Rojas, Pedro Patarroyo, Liang Mao et al. · 2017 · Geology

Large-scale biogeographic provinces of Cretaceous ammonoids, as currently defined in the literature, were delimited using qualitative assessments of taxonomic inventories. Using aggregated species occurrences in the Paleobiology Database, we generated a geographic network to quantify connectivity of Albian epicontinental basins and used the flow-based Infomap algorithm to delineate bioprovinces. Despite taxonomic, stratigraphic, and geographic limitations of the data, the Infomap bioprovinces are largely concordant with the traditional, qualitatively derived biogeographic model, including the

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Assimilation of pseudo-tree-ring-width observations into an atmospheric general circulation model

Walter Acevedo, Bijan Fallah, Sebastian Reich et al. · 2017 · Climate of the past

Abstract. Paleoclimate data assimilation (DA) is a promising technique to systematically combine the information from climate model simulations and proxy records. Here, we investigate the assimilation of tree-ring-width (TRW) chronologies into an atmospheric global climate model using ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) techniques and a process-based tree-growth forward model as an observation operator. Our results, within a perfect-model experiment setting, indicate that the "online DA" approach did not outperform the "off-line" one, despite its considerable additional implementation complexity. On

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Melt addition to mid-ocean ridge peridotites increases spinel Cr# with no significant effect on recorded oxygen fugacity

Suzanne Birner, Elizabeth Cottrell, J. M. Warren et al. · 2021 · Earth and Planetary Science Letters

Mid-ocean ridge peridotites record significantly greater variability in major and trace elements, isotopic compositions, and thermodynamic properties such as oxygen fugacity (fO2) than do their basaltic counterparts. This variability may derive from modern ridge processes related to melting and melt-rock interaction or from long-lived source heterogeneity related to recycled material or ancient melting events. In this study, we investigate variations in spinel geochemistry as well as silicate major and trace element chemistry and oxygen fugacity of a suite of peridotites from a single segment

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportEarth and Planetary Sciences

Contrasting Air Mass Advection Explains Significant Differences in Boundary Layer Depth Seasonal Cycles Under Onshore Versus Offshore Flows

Sandip Pal, Temple R. Lee · 2019 · Geophysical Research Letters

Abstract The complexities in the atmospheric boundary layer depth (BLD) features over coastal regions pose challenges for meteorological forecasts, air quality, greenhouse gas mixing and transport, and wind energy production. Here, for the…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

No statistically significant effect of a short-term decrease in the nucleation rate on atmospheric aerosols

E. M. Dunne, Lindsay Lee, Carly Reddington et al. · 2012 · Atmospheric chemistry and physics

Abstract. Observed correlations between short-term decreases in cosmic ray ionisation and cloud and aerosol properties have been attributed to short-term decreases in the ion-induced nucleation rate. We use a global aerosol microphysics model to determine whether a 10 day reduction of 15% in the nucleation rate could generate a statistically significant response in aerosol concentrations and optical properties. As an upper limit to the possible effect of changes in ion-induced nucleation rate, we perturb the total nucleation rate, which has been shown to generate particle concentrations and nu

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Machine learning modelling of a nonlinear environmental index with sensitivity analysis for groundwater assessment

Aliasghar Azma, Yakun Liu, Eden Tatek Alemu · 2026 · Scientific Reports

The aim of this study was to evaluate groundwater quality the Marvdasht aquifer using the Groundwater Quality Index (GWQI), which was determined using a conventional method and also predicted using three machine learning algorithms:…

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Brief Episodes of Nocturnal Hypoxia and Acidification Reduce Survival of Economically Important Blue Crab (Callinectes sapidus) Larvae

Stephen J. Tomasetti, Jeffrey R. Kraemer, Christopher J. Gobler · 2021 · Frontiers in Marine Science

Many shallow coastal systems experience diel fluctuations in dissolved oxygen (DO) and pH that can intensify throughout the summer season and expose estuarine organisms to repeated episodes of coastal hypoxia and acidification. In temperate regions, larval release of the economically important blue crab Callinectes sapidus occurs in the summer, and while the earliest stage (zoea I) larvae are susceptible to persistent low DO and low pH conditions, their sensitivity to diel fluctuations is unknown. Here, a series of short-term (≤96 h) experiments were conducted to investigate the survival of C.

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Revising the Giant Planet Mass–Metallicity Relation: Deciphering the Formation Sequence of Giant Planets

Yayaati Chachan, Jonathan J. Fortney, Kazumasa Ohno et al. · 2025 · The Astrophysical Journal

Abstract The rate at which giant planets accumulate solids and gas is a critical component of planet formation models, yet it is extremely challenging to predict from first principles. Characterizing the heavy element (everything other than hydrogen and helium) content of giant planets provides important clues about their provenance. Using thermal evolution models with an updated H–He equation of state and atmospheric boundary conditions that vary with envelope metallicity, we quantify the bulk heavy element content of 147 warm (<1000 K) giant planets with well-measured masses and radii, mo

View details →
Negative / Null Result ReportOpen accessEarth and Planetary Sciences

Evolutionary assembly of crown reptile anatomy clarified by late Paleozoic relatives of Neodiapsida

Xavier A. Jenkins, Roger Benson, David P. Ford et al. · 2025 · Peer Community Journal

Living reptiles include more than 20,000 species with disparate ecologies. Direct anatomical evidence from Neodiapsida, which includes the reptile crown-group and its closest extinct relatives, shows that this diversity originates from a single common ancestor that lived over 255 million years ago in the Paleozoic. However, the evolutionary assembly of crown reptile traits is poorly understood due to the lack of anatomically close relatives of Neodiapsida. We present a substantially revised phylogenetic hypothesis, informed by new anatomical data from high-resolution synchrotron tomography of

View details →